83% of Patients Choose Dentists Based on Google Reviews - Are You Missing Out?

Would you choose a dentist without checking their reviews? Why would your patients not read reviews as well? The importance of positive reviews cannot be overstated for dental practices.

1,026 U.S. adult consumers responded to BrightLocal’s 2025 Local Review Survey. Beyond the 83% who use Google reviews, 74% say they use two or more review sites before making decisions.

Consistently acquiring a consistent stream of positive reviews is essential to new patient acquisition and your practice’s brand strategy.

Read on to find out why positive reviews are so critical to your success. 

Brightlocal 2025 Local Consumer Review Survey DataVisual Infographic

The Importance of Reviews: Building Credibility and Trust Online

All local businesses including dental practices have a reputation. Each person who talks or writes about you colors how a person will see your brand.

The same is true for what reviewers report about the dentists in your practice. And also the hygienists and administration staff in your office.

From the beginning, you want potential patients to see glowing details about your practice. And this will lead to appointments and an office visit.

Why Dentists Need Patients to Leave Reviews Online

In the 2025 survey previously mentioned, 42% of consumers trust reviews as much as personal recommendations from friends and family. 

BrightLocal 2025 Consumer Review Survey: 42 percent of consumers trust reviews as mush as personal recommendations from friends and family

Patient reviews are how a practice attracts additional patients. They get valuable insights from what your current dental patients have to say about your dentists and your practice.

What they write on review sites reflects on the entire team in your dental office. And it determines your practice's and dentists' reputations.

Reviews also affect your search engine rankings. Your success in the dental industry relies on how well you manage your online reviews.

53% of Your Patients Want to Read Reviews About Dental Offices

The two main reasons patients choose dentists are personal referrals and feedback in online reviews. It is how they gain valuable insights on where to find the best possible care.

Your patients may mention anything from why they chose your practice to the type of services and treatment plans you offer.

They want to know how professional everyone working in your office is. But most importantly, they want to know about any concerns others report.

In the dental industry, the offices with the most helpful reviews and feedback garner the lion's share of patients.

Feature your best reviews on your website's pages and mention them in blog posts. Ideally, display reviews containing details that focus on each of the services you offer on the service page.

How Reviews Shape Dental Practice Reputations

All of your reviews are the foundation of your local business's reputation. And they can all affect your visibility in search engines.

Local Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

Google reviews for dentists directly impact local search results rankings. Google's algorithm considers several review-related factors:

  • Quantity: Practices with more reviews typically rank higher in local search results
  • Recency: Fresh reviews signal an active, thriving practice
  • Diversity: Reviews across multiple platforms demonstrate broader patient satisfaction
  • Keyword relevance: Reviews containing location and service-specific keywords boost local SEO

Patient Acquisition and Conversion

The impact of reviews on a dental office's reputation extends far beyond search rankings. Reviews serve as a pre-qualification tool that:

  • Reduces patient acquisition costs by attracting prospects who already have a favorable opinion
  • Increases conversion rates from website visits to appointment bookings
  • Builds trust before the first patient interaction
  • Addresses common patient concerns proactively

Competitive Advantage

In saturated dental markets, online reviews for dentists create significant competitive differentiation. Practices with strong review profiles often:

  • Command higher fees due to perceived value
  • Experience reduced price sensitivity among patients
  • Attract patients from competitors with weaker review profiles
  • Build stronger patient loyalty and retention

Which Review Sites Matter Most?

Local businesses are hopefully aware they need online reviews on Google Business Profiles (GBP). But there are other review sites that impact your visibility.

If anonymous reviews have concerned you in the past, you'll be happy to know that Google no longer permits them as of May 2018. 

Google Maps Google Business Profiles GBPs for Las Vegas NV dentists

Google Maps Google Business Profiles GBPs for Las Vegas NV dentists

 

Apple iOS Makes Yelp Reviews Valuable

Are you aware that Apple iOS devices favored by affluent users pull from Yelp reviews? Also, Bing and Apple Maps both use Yelp rather than Google.

Approximately 2.35 billion Apple devices worldwide have Apple Maps preinstalled. In the U.S., iOS controls 58.65% of the mobile device market as of May 2025 vs Android's 41.1%.

This makes Yelp more important than many suspect. But you only want Yelp reviews from your patients who regularly use Yelp. We'll explain why in Maui Bob's 5 Star Reviews System.

Yelp Reviews for Las Vegas Dentists
Yelp Reviews for Las Vegas Dentists

Patients Use Local News to Verify a Dental Practice's Reputation

Surprisingly, Yelp reviews weren't the second most popular after Google reviews. BrightLocal's survey discovered that 48% of respondents mentioned using local news to choose local businesses to patronize.

While most local news websites do not have review sections, they often have community spaces where locals share helpful feedback.

Especially now with AI overviews taking away clicks, your dental practice will want to give more attention to PR and mentions like the one below on local websites.

Example of a Local News Mention: Las Vegas Review-Journal story about Changing Smiles Pediatric Dentistry
Example of a Local News Mention: Las Vegas Review-Journal story about Changing Smiles Pediatric Dentistry

Online Reviews on Social Media Platforms

Your Google Business Profile and Yelp aren't the only places potential patients use to find a new dentist. The Nielsen Trust in Advertising Survey sometimes asks what people trust most:

Recommendations from friends and family consistently ranks #1 with 89%. And where are more friends and family of potential patients likely to be than Facebook?

Facebook can be one of the more problematic review sites for dental practices. Your dental office cannot remove negative reviews yourself.

Facebook Reviews for Las Vegas Dental Group
Facebook Reviews for Las Vegas Dental Group

And it is critical to continually monitor feedback received on Facebook because spam is a pervasive issue there. All spam reviews need to be immediately reported for removal.

But having positive reviews, strong ratings, and immediately posting review responses on Facebook builds trust and credibility.

It is worth the effort to be active on social media platforms, especially Facebook. Just take a deep breath before you respond if you get a negative review.

While they don't officially have reviews, opinions on dental practices are often shared on Instagram and even TikTok.

Here's an example of a patient who shared on Instagram that they love their dental office:

Instagram comment recommending True Dentistry Dental Practice LV Nevada
Instagram comment recommending True Dentistry Dental Practice LV Nevada

Monitor mentions of your dental practice across all social media networks. And respond promptly to both positive and negative reviews.

You never know when potential patients will see what is said about you on social media. If you comment, always respond in a professional manner.

This shows an effort to resolve any complaints and is an effective way to impress prospective patients.

Why New Online Reviews Are Essential to Dental Practices

One of the things that Google takes into consideration for a business is how relevant you are. How often you are mentioned on social media, how many reviews you have, and how often you get new reviews all matter.  

From our experience, any review after 30 days becomes less likely to influence where you appear in Google Maps. Why, you ask?

Well, an old review is better than no review; however, a few things come to mind if you haven't gotten a review within 30 days.

If you have your dentists and others in your practice asking for reviews, you should get regular new reviews just as Lone Mountain Dental in Las Vegas does.

Many New Reviews for Lone Mountain Dental Office Las Vegas
Many New Reviews for Lone Mountain Dental Office Las Vegas

Now this next part is mostly subjective, but you will find it true yourself as a reader. When looking at reviews and you haven't seen a new review in a month or more, I personally wonder is this place that busy?

Do people think it's worth their time and money? Or perhaps the service wasn't good enough to want to write about it?

Now, maybe you don't think about this. However, there are a lot of people who think this way, so consistently asking for reviews is important.

And ask for Google reviews in particular because they are the most commonly used search engine and they rate you off of relevance and your reviews.

Negative Patient Reviews Hurt

Unfortunately, there is no sure-fire way to avoid all negative reviews. But the best protection against bad ratings is having a large number of reviews.

Here's an excellent example. Even though Las Vegas Modern Dentistry and Orthodontics has negative reviews, their rating is 4.8 due to their 544 total reviews (as of today):

Even a Dental Practice with 544 reviews will have some lower than 5 stars
Even a Dental Practice with 544 reviews will have some lower than 5 stars

Did you know that people don't trust responses that are all five stars? It makes them suspicious that you may have paid someone to submit fake reviews.

A mix of mostly good, but some less than stellar responses in reviews for local businesses is normal. And it increases trust that the responses about dentists are real.

No matter whether a patient's responses on reviews are positive or negative, respond to every one in a professional manner.

Focus on making the unhappy patients satisfied. And be sure to show appreciation for the ones who love their dentists and were kind enough to leave a review!

So rather than dreading a negative review or spending unnecessary time and money trying to get it removed, just accept that it happens (since you can't please everyone).

And then bury it with more good reviews. Your friendly staff following your review requests process is key to higher ratings and more positive reviews.

Stop Losing Patients to Bad (or Missing) Reviews

As soon you are done reading this, do two things:

  1. Accept the fact that you may eventually get a negative review. And that may hurt for a little bit, but don't let it bother you too deeply. Use any valid feedback to improve services.
  2. Make sure your staff is trained to consistently mention filling out reviews and understand the importance of this process.

You'll find out in 7 Rules to Help You Gain 347% More Reviews how to make it easy. At the moment your patients are happy, make contact with them and ask for a review.

When you provide a QR code and link that drops patients right into a review, in most cases patients are happy to give feedback on your business.

You can find more tips in Why Your Best Patients Never Leave Reviews (And How to Change That).

Can Your Dental Practice Survive Without Good Reviews?

We've established that your potential patients do seek out and read reviews. And that they use multiple review sites before deciding to make appointments.

It is essential that you have a process to send them review requests. This is because you need to consistently generate recent reviews.

Explain the importance of requesting reviews to each of your dentists and other staff. It truly does make a huge difference in the number of new visits you can generate.

Justin

About the Author - Justin Morgan

Justin Morgan is the CEO and founder of what most of us affectionately refer to as the “DMG.” From all circles within the dental industry who address dental marketing as a topic, Justin Morgan is the dental marketing guy that everyone keeps talking about.

Table of Contents

Do you have unanswered dental marketing questions?

Yes, Grow My Practice!
chevron-down